Split/Shared Visit Checker
A physician and an NPP both saw the patient — so who bills the visit? Under the CMS split/shared rules it is whoever performed the substantive portion. Enter the minutes and the decision-making split and find out, with the modifier and the payment rate spelled out.
Two clinicians, one visit, one claim — and the wrong name on it costs 15%. When a physician and a nurse practitioner or physician assistant share an E/M visit in a facility, Medicare pays the practitioner who performed the substantive portion — more than half of the total time, or a substantive part of the medical decision making (since January 1, 2024). The physician bills at 100% of the fee schedule; the NPP bills at 85%. Work out who bills below, before the claim goes out.
Check your split/shared visit
1. Setting
2. Time on the visit (minutes, on the date of service)
Count the E/M time rules: preparing and reviewing, history, examination, documentation and care coordination on the day of the visit. Enter each practitioner's minutes apart from any time you spent together, then the joint minutes separately.
3. Medical decision making
Worked examples
| Visit | Physician | NPP | Joint (led by) | Total | Who bills |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hospital follow-up | 20 min | 15 min | 5 min (physician) | 40 min | Physician — 25 of 40 min, more than half |
| Observation visit | 10 min | 25 min | 5 min (NPP) | 40 min | NPP — 30 of 40 min, more than half (85%) |
| Even split, MDM decides | 20 min | 20 min | 0 min | 40 min | Neither by time (20 is not more than half of 40) — the practitioner who did the substantive part of the MDM bills |
| Critical care | 30 min | 20 min | 10 min (physician) | 60 min | Physician — 40 of 60 min by time; MDM cannot decide a critical care visit |
Note the even-split row: exactly half is not more than half. When time ties, the MDM path is the only way the physician can bill at 100% — and the note must show the physician made or approved the management plan and accepted responsibility for it.
Split/shared vs incident-to — do not mix them up
| Split/shared visit | Incident-to | Direct NPP billing | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Setting | Facility only (hospital, observation, ED, SNF) | Office / clinic only | Any setting |
| Who bills | Whoever performed the substantive portion | The supervising physician | The NPP |
| Medicare payment | 100% if the physician bills, 85% if the NPP bills | 100% of the fee schedule | 85% of the fee schedule |
| Modifier | FS on the E/M code | None (FR only if supervision was by two-way audio/video) | None |
| Key condition | Same group; either could have billed the visit alone | Physician did the initial service, stays actively involved, directly supervises | NPP works within scope and state law |
Documentation checklist for the chart
- Both practitioners identified — the note names the physician and the NPP and says what each one personally did.
- Separate minutes recorded — each practitioner's time is documented, and any joint time is shown once, not counted twice.
- Substantive portion stated — the note says plainly who performed the substantive portion and how (more than half the time, or the substantive part of the MDM).
- MDM ownership — if MDM decides, the billing practitioner made or approved the management plan and accepted responsibility for it, with its risks. A physician addendum that only says "agree" is not enough on its own.
- Face-to-face contact — at least one of the two practitioners saw the patient in person.
- Modifier FS on the claim — appended to the E/M code, billed under the NPI of the practitioner who performed the substantive portion.
Rules: CMS Medicare Claims Processing Manual, chapter 12, section 30.6.18; 42 CFR 415.140; CY 2024 Medicare Physician Fee Schedule final rule (substantive portion = more than half of total time, or a substantive part of the medical decision making; critical care uses time only). NPP payment at 85% of the fee schedule: Social Security Act section 1834. This checker is educational guidance, not billing advice — verify against your Medicare Administrative Contractor's current guidance before submitting. Nothing you enter leaves your browser.
Disclaimer: This tool is for educational and estimation purposes only and does not constitute billing, coding or medical advice. Coverage, coding and payment rules vary by payer and change over time — always verify with the current CMS files and the payer's own policy before submitting claims or making financial decisions.
Frequently asked questions
What is a split/shared visit?
A split (or shared) visit is an evaluation and management (E/M) visit in a facility setting — hospital inpatient, observation, emergency department, skilled nursing facility — that is performed in part by both a physician and a nonphysician practitioner (NPP, such as a nurse practitioner or physician assistant) who are in the same group. The service must be one that either practitioner could have billed alone. Payment goes to the practitioner who performed the substantive portion of the visit, billed under that practitioner's own NPI, with modifier FS on the E/M code.
What counts as the 'substantive portion' in 2024 and later?
Since January 1, 2024, the substantive portion is either more than half of the total time the physician and the NPP spent on the visit, or a substantive part of the medical decision making (MDM). Either path can decide who bills. For critical care visits and prolonged services, only time counts — the substantive portion is more than half of the total time. This checker applies both paths and tells you which one decided the answer.
Does a split/shared visit work in the office or clinic?
No. Split/shared rules apply only in facility settings, where incident-to billing is not allowed. In an office or clinic, a visit shared between a physician and an NPP is handled under the incident-to rules (the physician must have performed the initial service and be actively involved, and must directly supervise) or billed directly under the NPP at 85%. If you select an office setting in this checker, it will tell you the visit is not a split/shared visit.
How is time counted, and what about time spent together?
Total time is the time the physician and the NPP spent on the visit on the date of service, following the same E/M time-counting rules (reviewing tests, obtaining history, examining the patient, documentation, care coordination that day). When both practitioners are together with the patient or discussing the patient, that time counts only once toward the total. In this checker you enter each practitioner's minutes apart from the joint minutes, then the joint minutes and who led them — the joint minutes are credited to the practitioner who led that part. One practitioner must have had face-to-face contact with the patient.
What is the payment difference between billing as the physician and as the NPP?
A visit billed under the physician's NPI is paid at 100% of the Medicare Physician Fee Schedule amount; the same visit billed under the NPP's NPI is paid at 85%. That 15-point gap is the whole financial point of getting the substantive portion right — and of documenting it, because an auditor will ask who did what. Enter the fee schedule amount for the E/M code in the checker to see both figures side by side.
What is modifier FS, and what about modifier FR?
Modifier FS (split or shared E/M visit) is appended to the E/M code on the claim to identify the visit as split/shared. Modifier FR is not a split/shared modifier — it marks that a supervising practitioner was present through two-way audio and video, and belongs to incident-to supervision. Do not append FR to a split/shared claim.
